A big issue though is that you can’t move other people’s projects for them. If I want to contribute to Immich, I have to be on GitHub. Cloning it somewhere the maintainers aren’t looking or accepting contributions does nothing.

I mean I’m not really concerned about it being actually private, I just need to not have asset creators become pissed at me for publicly hosting their paid assets. Self hosting forgejo is on my to-do list but until then I’m using GitHub as a free project host for my unity/blender projects with paid assets. A single one of those projects easily blows past the codeberg 100MB private repo limit.

Besides that, basically the only use I have for GitHub is to contribute to repos on GitHub or to open / comment on issues. So it feels kind of useless to use codeberg since it defeats the whole purpose when the repos I want to interact with aren’t there.

Self hosting also means I wouldn’t be able to accept PRs, comments, or issues from other people unless I let them create accounts, which is something I don’t want to moderate. I was waiting for forgejo to get federation to self host it but I haven’t seen an update from them about that in a while.

So basically there are 2 things I use GitHub for:

• Keeping private projects safe, which are too big for codeberg to allow
• Opening issues on repos that are on GitHub, so using codeberg completely defeats the purpose

Codeberg is like a GitHub where the projects I want to interact with don’t exist, and copying the projects there doesn’t help me give feedback to the original authors.

It’s for private repos only, so if you cloned public repos that wouldn’t count towards the limit.

And it sounds like it’s total for your whole account, you can read about it here:

https://codeberg.org/Codeberg-e.V./requests

Storing private repositories is allowed for things related to Free Software, or small content like personal notes. It is limited to 100 MiB per user.

And: https://docs.codeberg.org/getting-started/faq/#how-about-private-repositories?

Codeberg’s mission is to promote free/libre software. Keeping software private is obviously not our primary use case, but we acknowledge that private repositories are useful or necessary at times.

• If you are a contributor to free/libre software projects, we allow up to 100 MB of private content for your convenience. Use it for your personal notes, your side project or any other you want to keep private.

So yeah, my unity projects with paid assets are ostensibly “side projects”, but 100MB is less than the size of the unity project file or blender assets. So if I can’t use codeberg to keep my unity projects, and I can’t use it to contribute to projects that live on GitHub (like Immich), or to host forks of projects for the original authors to see where the original repo and author is on GitHub, I basically can only use it to mirror projects that I want to “put out into the world” with no specific audience in mind. And for that purpose, so few people ever actually come across my projects that I feel like I might as well just email them to myself.

The biggest use case for using GitHub for me is to interact with people and projects that are on GitHub.

One thing that keeps me from using codeberg more is that private repos are limited to 100MB. So I still need to use GitHub to keep some of my personal projects that contain purchased assets that can’t be made public. I do still have a codeberg account and mirror what I can, but it means I can’t stop using GitHub for now.

As a web dev I hate the trend of websites relying on chromium-specific quirks, there are a handful of sites I need to use which refuse to work in any non-chromium browser, and customer support will always tell you to just use chrome as if you’re not a normal person for using Firefox. So yeah what’s wrong with chromium to me is that it’s the new internet explorer when it comes to web standards. Websites and large businesses can afford to just not care if they are following web standards as long as it works in chrome, and if you have a problem it’s your fault for not using chrome.